Hillary Clinton’s path to the nomination is uncontested no longer. Senator Bernie Sanders is drawing huge crowds and gaining in the polls. But can a democratic socialist win over America? Spencer Kimball reports.
It’s a dirty word in American politics. But Bernie Sanders embraces it.
“I wouldn’t deny it, not for one second, ” Sanders told the Washington Post when he was running for Vermont’s senate seat back in 2006. “I’m a democratic socialist.”
Sanders is not a conventional American politician. He’s the longest serving independent in the history of the US Congress. Though he’s long worked with Democrats, Sanders officially joined the party just this year to challenge Hillary Clinton for the presidential nomination.
Initially considered a fringe candidate, he’s defying expectations. In May, Sanders trailed Clinton by 45 percent in Iowa, a key early primary state. He’s reduced the margin to 19 percent. In New Hampshire, the Vermont senator is behind by only eight points.
Sanders drew a crowd of some 10,000 people in Madison, Wisconsin earlier this month. It was easily one of the largest rallies of the 2016 campaign to date – in either party. And he’s no one-hit wonder. On Monday, he drew more than 7,000 people in Portland, Maine.
“No one in the White House will have the power to take on Wall Street alone, corporate America alone, the billionaire classes alone,” Sanders told his supporters in Maine.
“The only way that change takes place is when we develop that strong grassroots movement, make that political revolution, stand together, and then we bring about change,” he said.
Scandinavian America
What would the US look like after Sanders’ political revolution? Think Scandinavia – Denmark, Norway and Sweden.
“In those countries health care is a right of all people, in those countries college education, graduate school is free, in those countries retirement benefits, child care are stronger than in the United States of America,” Sanders said in an interview on the Sunday morning talk show This Week.
“In those countries, by and large, the government works for ordinary people and the middle class rather than, as is the case right now in our country, for the billionaire class,” Sanders said.
It’s a message that appeals to progressives. But will the broader American public support a self-proclaimed democratic socialist who wants the nation to look more like northern Europe?
“This is a country that had a McCarthy era and a red scare,” John Nichols, Washington correspondent for “The Nation” magazine, told DW. “It had red baiting and attacks on socialists, that’s part of our media life even in recent years.”
Challenging economic orthodoxy
Nichols has covered Sanders for years and introduced the Vermont senator at his packed rally in Wisconsin. Though America is very different from Europe structurally and economically, Nichols believes the country is ripe for the populist anti-austerity message that has swept the Old Continent in recent months, and Sanders is trying to tap into that sentiment.
According to Gallup, two out of every three Americans are dissatisfied with the way wealth is distributed in the United States. It’s a bi-partisan issue. Three-quarters of Democrats and even 54 percent of Republicans are concerned about income inequality.
“There’s space in the 2016 race for messages that really do challenge the economic orthodoxies of the United States,” Nichols said.
Generational gap
While the older baby-boom generation is more invested in the status quo and came of age when the socialist label was taboo, Alexandra Reckendorf believes the younger millennial generation is more open to radical change.
“They’re a little bit more compassionate and empathetic on these issues of economic inequality,”
Reckendorf, an expert on US politics at Virginia Commonwealth University, told DW. “A lot of them either find themselves in that boat or are still young and idealistic enough to think that these changes could work.”
Young Americans have racked up $1.2 trillion (1.08 trillion euros) in student debt due to the rising cost of college tuition. Sanders has introduced legislation to make all four-year public colleges tuition free, and would finance it through a tax on Wall Street speculation.
Uphill battle
But according to Arthur Sanders (no relation), the broader public just is not there yet. The US politics expert points to Obamacare. Only 43 percent of the public has a favorable view of President Obama’s signature domestic accomplishment, according to a Kaiser Health Tracking poll. Senator Sanders, on the other hand, thinks Obama’s health care reforms don’t go far enough.
“If he’s going to argue as he did in the past for single-payer government health care, the public is not ready for that, they’re barely ready for Obamacare,” Arthur Sanders, a professor at Drake University in Des Moines, Iowa, told DW.
And so far, Senator Sanders also hasn’t made inroads with African American and Latino voters, who overwhelmingly support Hillary Clinton. Though he was involved in the civil rights movement in Chicago during the 1960s, he now represents an overwhelmingly white state in New England.
He’s also refused to accept corporate money out of principle. While Hillary Clinton has raised $45 million, Senator Sanders has pulled in $15 million from small donors. Regardless of whether or not he can secure the nomination, the democratic socialist senator from Vermont is already having a significant influence on the debate. And perhaps that’s his real objective.
“He’ll push Clinton to the left, he’ll push the debate to the left,” Arthur Sanders said. “He’ll never say that’s why he’s running, because you can’t say that’s why you’re running.”