Gagrule.net

Gagrule.net News, Views, Interviews worldwide

  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • GagruleLive
  • Armenia profile

Erdogan addresses the Armenians, Alevis and journalists to sexual minorities

June 4, 2015 By administrator

arton112707-400x300Erdogâneries. Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan made again evidence of racism and sectarianism by attacking journalists, Armenians, religious minorities and sexual minorities …! Erdogan has implemented a policy of exclusion of minorities was first criticized in a public speech the opposition Kurdish HDP (Kurdish Democratic People). Then its momentum, Turkish President has attacked the opposition party People’s Republican CHP. Finally to complete the whole Erdogan criticized the Armenian media Doghan journalists, Alevis and homosexuals. Its momentum Decidedly very inspired today LA- he said that “the Armenian lobby”, homosexuals, the Alevis and Doghan media journalists were those who supported the HDP and the CHP. Nothing less …

Erdogan whose regime openly supported by the delivery of arms, mercenaries and logistics support the Islamists in Iraq and Syria.

Krikor Amirzayan

Filed Under: Articles Tagged With: alevis, Armenian, attack, Erdogan, Journalist

Turkey Whistleblower claims journalists, members of judiciary to be detained en masse

June 1, 2015 By administrator

A screenshot taken from whistleblower fuatavni’s Twitter account. (Photo: Today's Zaman)

A screenshot taken from whistleblower fuatavni’s Twitter account. (Photo: Today’s Zaman)

A week before the country’s June 7 parliamentary elections, Turkey‘s prominent whistleblower Fuat Avni has claimed that there is soon to be a mass detention of journalists and members of the judiciary as part of government efforts to muzzle media outlets which are free, independent and critical.

The whistleblower, known on Twitter by the pseudonym Fuat Avni, said some 200 people will be detained in a major sweep that has been ordered by the embattled President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, who is reportedly furious over the publication by the Cumhuriyet daily of photos of weapons being carried to radical groups in Syria by trucks run by Turkey’s intelligence organization.

Avni said Erdoğan has become very concerned over a possible trial in the International Criminal Court for sending arms to Syrian groups, which allegedly included al-Qaeda and the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL). Turkey’s president appears to want to divert public attention by launching the en masse detention of journalists, which is supposed to include the chief editor of Cumhuriyet, Can Dündar.

Erdoğan is also reportedly concerned that after the elections, the ruling Justice and Development Party (AK Party) may not secure enough seats to establish a single party government, and therefore a witch hunt he has been pursuing since corruption scandals in 2013 may be interrupted.

According to Fuat Avni, the government will detain scores of journalists critical to the government, including Ekrem Dumanlı, the editor-in chief of Zaman, the country’s largest circulated national daily; Bülent Keneş, the editor-in-chief of Today’s Zaman; Kerim Balcı, the editor-in-chief of Turkish Review, a bimonthly news magazine; Celil Sağır, the managing editor of Today’s Zaman; Faruk Mercan, the Ankara representative of Bugün TV; Adem Yavuz Arslan, the Washington bureau chief for the Bugün newspaper; Nazlı Ilıcak, a veteran columnist at Bugün; Yasemin Çongar, former editor of Taraf daily; Ahmet Altan, former editor-in-chief of Taraf, Emre Uslu, columnist at Today’s Zaman, and finally Cumhuriyet’s Can Dündar.

The politically-motivated investigations included not only journalists but also the corporate entities of Zaman, Samanyolu and Bugün media outlets.

Police chiefs and members of the judiciary who were involved in landmark cases that exposed wrongdoings in the government and the military are also targeted in the sweep, Avni claimed.

Avni has revealed many government-backed police operations to the public in the past, and though late at times, all the claims have turned out to be true.

He also said Prime Minister Ahmet Davutoğlu is opposed to any mass detentions taking place so soon before the elections, fearing a backlash from voters.

Filed Under: Articles Tagged With: detained, Erdogan, Journalist, Turkey

Erdogan vows to punish journalist for publishing Syria trucks video

June 1, 2015 By administrator

193072Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan has vowed to punish the editor of a newspaper which published video footage it said showed the MIT state intelligence agency helping send weapons to Syria.

The Cumhuriyet newspaper published footage on its website which it said showed gendarmerie and police officers opening crates of what it described as weapons and ammunition on the back of three trucks belonging to MIT.

“The individual who has reported this as an exclusive story will pay a high price for this,” Erdogan said in a television interview with state broadcaster TRT late on Sunday, May 31.

“I will not let this go.”

Reuters said it reported on May 21 that witnesses and prosecutors have alleged that MIT helped deliver arms to parts of Syria under Islamist rebel control during late 2013 and early 2014, quoting a prosecutor and court testimony from gendarmerie officers.

Cumhuriyet said the video was from Jan 19, 2014 but did not say how it had obtained the footage. Erdogan has said the trucks stopped that day belonged to MIT and were carrying aid to Turkmens in Syria. He has said prosecutors had no authority to search MIT vehicles and were part of what he calls a “parallel state” run by his ally-turned-foe Fethullah Gulen, a U.S.-based Islamic cleric whom Erdogan says is bent on discrediting him and the government.

“These allegations against the national intelligence agency and this illegal operation is some kind of espionage activity. This paper is now involved in this espionage,” Erdogan said, adding that he had instructed his lawyer to file a lawsuit.

The state-run Anadolu news agency said on Friday that the Istanbul chief prosecutor’s office had launched an investigation into Cumhuriyet’s editor-in-chief Can Dundar under counter-terrorism laws. Reuters could not reach Dundar for comment, but he defended the newspaper’s coverage on his Twitter account.

“We are journalists, not civil servants. Our duty is not to hide the dirty secrets of the state but to hold those accountable on behalf of the people,” he said in a tweet on Monday.

Prime Minister Ahmet Davutoglu also said at the weekend that the trucks were carrying aid for Turkmens but declined to comment on their content.

“It is nobody’s business what was inside the trucks. Yes there were serious clashes in Syria and we helped the Turkmens,” Davutoglu said on Sunday in a Haberturk television interview.

Related links:

Reuters. Turkey’s Erdogan vows to punish journalist behind Syria trucks video

Filed Under: Articles Tagged With: Erdogan, Journalist, Syrian, VIDEO)

Turkey: Independent journalism struggling for survival in Turkey on World Press Freedom Day

May 3, 2015 By administrator

Journalists, joined by some opposition deputies, march on İstiklal Street in downtown İstanbul

Journalists, joined by some opposition deputies, march on İstiklal Street in downtown İstanbul

Turkish journalists marked World Press Freedom Day on Sunday under a cloud of diminishing press freedom in Turkey amid growing threats to their profession as they face unprecedented and constant attacks on their independence and safety.

Observed annually on May 3, World Press Freedom Day is promoted by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) to celebrate the fundamental principles of press freedom and to address current challenges and solutions. The theme of this year’s press freedom day is “Let Journalism Thrive! Towards better reporting, gender equality and media safety in the digital age.”

Far from thriving, free and independent journalism is apparently battling to survive in Turkey as not one day seems to pass without journalists’ facing the most severe forms of repression: A number of them are either in jail, losing their jobs or dealing with legal charges rained down on them by President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and the ruling Justice and Development Party (AK Party).

Turkish journalists face threats and intimidation not only from Erdoğan and the AK Party government but also from their advocates in the media.

On Saturday Cem Küçük, a columnist for the Star daily who is known for his threatening and aggressive language, used his column to call on the authorities to seize or freeze the assets of media outlets owned by people motivated by the ideas of Turkish-Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen, who inspired the Gülen or Hizmet movement.

Erdoğan and the AK Party government launched a battle against the movement after a corruption probe went public on Dec. 17, 2013, implicating senior members of the government, sons of three now-former ministers and government-affiliated figures. They accuse the movement of establishing a “parallel state” and plotting to topple the government, while the movement strongly denies the charges.

Describing the movement as a terrorist organization despite a complete lack of any evidence substantiating the claim, Küçük wrote that because a terrorist organization would not be allowed to have media outlets, the necessary action needs to be taken.

He called the movement a “clear and present danger,” adding that the bureaucracy needs to take immediate action to seize the media outlets, such as Zaman, Bugün and Samanyolu TV, which are owned by people inspired by Gülen, and to cut their finances. Küçük also cited a number of laws that he claimed would provide the legal basis for such action.

On Sunday, to mark World Press Freedom Day, veteran journalists gathered in the old newspaper neighborhood of Cağaloğlu, İstanbul where they lamented the desperate state of Turkish media due to the oppression enforced by the AK Party that has brought the profession of journalism to a near impossible state.

Various press organizations, including the Press Union of the Confederation of Revolutionary Workers’ Unions (DİSK), the Turkish Journalists’ Association (TGC), Turkish Journalists’ Union (TGS), Freedom for Journalists Platform (GÖP) and Contemporary Journalists Association (ÇGD) convened for Sunday’s conference with veteran journalists such as Doğan Tılıç, Turgay Olcayto, Ahmet Abakay, Uğur Güç and Faruk Eren in attendance.

“Freedom of the press allows the public to be informed, to learn the truth and reality of what is happening, and prevents people from being left in the dark. Journalists are in very difficult positions right now with bans via court decisions, accreditation [issues] and both censorship and automatic self-censorship. Unfortunately, with this the rights of the public are being constrained,” explained TGC President Turgay Olcayto.

TGS President Uğur Güç, who talked about the lack of press freedom in Turkey, said there are currently 21 jailed journalists and hundreds of journalists spending their working hours attending court hearings to give their testimony. “Every day, there are new court cases being filed against journalists,” Güç emphasized.

For his part, DİSK President Faruk Eren accused the government of trying to enforce who can and cannot be journalists.

A statement was released by the Platform for Independent Journalism (P24) on World Press Freedom Day arguing that the day has become a day not to celebrate, but to reflect and mourn. Referring to the journalists who are in jail, the statement said the real victims of the restrictions on journalists are not only journalists but the society they are no longer able to serve.

“By drawing a noose around the media, Turkey is losing the ability to unite, solve its problems and plan ahead. When Turkey emerged from the indignity of martial law in the 1980s, when it developed private television and a freer press, the rallying cry was “konuşan Türkiye” [Turkey speaks] — a nation, able to raise its voice. On May 3, we spare a thought for a nation loosing the ability to converse, even with itself,” it added.

“Journalism in Turkey is in the intensive care unit,” noted P24’s statement.

Crackdown on independent media

There is already immense government pressure on media organs owned by people inspired by Gülen’s ideas. Along with Zaman Editor-in-Chief Ekrem Dumanlı, Samanyolu Broadcasting Group General Manager Hidayet Karaca was taken into custody on Dec. 14, 2014, as part of a government-backed police operation. While Dumanlı was released pending trial, Karaca was arrested and still remains in jail on suspicion of being a member of an armed organization. The charges against him are based on a fictional TV series that was broadcast a few years ago. Despite a court ruling last month, which called for the release of Karaca and 63 police officers arrested, then detained in government-orchestrated operations, they were not released. To compound matters, the judges who ruled their release were suspended and subsequently arrested in an apparent sign of growing political pressure on members of the judiciary in Turkey.

However, it is not only journalists who work for media outlets owned by people inspired by Gülen’s ideas that face prosecution and persecution at the hands of the government and Erdoğan. Dozens of other journalists also face legal action over charges of insulting Erdoğan or government officials in their newspaper articles, or on social media.

Sedef Kabaş, a TV presenter, is facing a prison sentence of up to five years for posting a tweet about a corruption probe involving high-profile individuals. Another journalist, Mehmet Baransu, is being held under arrest for publishing state documents, with the charge of revealing secret documents linked to national security. Columnist Mümtaz’er Türköne is facing legal charges due to his criticism of President Erdoğan and ruling AK Party members. Osman Özsoy was fired from the pro-government Yeni Şafak daily last year due to his critical stance against the government in the wake of the Dec. 17 graft probe. Özsoy announced on his Twitter account last Wednesday that he had been detained by counterterrorism police officers while disembarking a ferry in İstanbul for remarks he had made on a TV show last Tuesday.

Journalists barred from pursuing profession

In addition, some media outlets and journalists in Turkey that are critical of the government or President Erdoğan are subjected to a controversial accreditation ban and barred from covering events attended by any government official or Erdoğan.

There are claims that Erdoğan and the AK Party government aim to avoid being asked tough questions by critical journalists on a range of controversial issues by preventing these journalists from covering events they attend.

Main opposition Republican People’s Party (CHP) leader Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu took the opportunity in a speech he delivered at a General Assembly meeting of the Union of Chambers and Commodity Exchanges (TOBB) of Turkey on Saturday to draw attention to the government’s controversial accreditation practice. The practice was also in place at that meeting, which was attended by Prime Minister Ahmet Davutoğlu and other government members.

Referring to a speech delivered by Davutoğlu at the meeting, in which the prime minister talked about the importance of democracy, Kılıçdaroğlu recalled that the government had barred some journalists and TV channels from covering the event.

“This is not fair practice. There cannot be true democracy in a country whose media is not free. The raison d’être of democracy is the freedom of the media,” Kılıçdaroğlu said in his speech.

Turkey’s poor grades on press freedom

The growing sanctions faced by independent journalists in Turkey and the tightening government grip on the free media have made their way into the reports of international media watchdogs, which have criticized Turkey’s current level of press freedom.

The reports announced ahead of World Press Freedom Day indicate that press freedoms have considerably degraded. Freedom House’s 2015 report referred to Turkey as a country where the press is “not free.” According to the report, Turkey performed worse in this area last year than at any time in the past 10 years. It stressed that many journalists were targeted, threatened and arrested.

A year ago, in the 2014 report, Turkey had for the first time been demoted from one of the “partially free” countries to the “not free” countries. The 2015 report also noted that Turkey is among the countries where the rate of deterioration of press freedoms was the highest. Turkey is now the only country in Europe where the press is not free. The Turkish press is now considered to be more restricted than its traditionally less democratic counterparts in Bangladesh, Indonesia, Uganda, Tanzania and Kenya.

In the meantime, veteran journalists gathered in the old newspaper neighborhood of Cağaloğlu, İstanbul on Sunday to mark World Press Freedom Day where they lamented the desperate state of Turkish media due to the oppression enforced by the Justice and Development Party (AK Party) that has brought the profession of journalism to a near impossible state.

Various press organizations, including the Press Union of the Confederation of Revolutionary Workers’ Unions (DİSK), the Turkish Journalists’ Association (TGC), Turkish Journalists’ Union (TGS), Freedom for Journalists Platform (GÖP) and Contemporary Journalists Association (ÇGD) convened for Sunday’s conference with veteran journalists such as Doğan Tılıç, Turgay Olcayto, Ahmet Abakay, Uğur Güç and Faruk Eren in attendance.

“Freedom of the press allows the public to be informed, to learn the truth and reality of what is happening, and prevents people from being left in the dark. Journalists are in very difficult positions right now with bans via court decisions, accreditation [issues] and both censorship and automatic self-censorship. Unfortunately, with this the rights of the public are being constrained,” explained TGC President Turgay Olcayto.

TGS President Uğur Güç, who talked about the lack of press freedom in Turkey, said there are currently 21 jailed journalists and hundreds of journalists spending their working hours attending court hearings to give their testimony. “Every day, there are new court cases being filed against journalists,” Güç emphasized.

For his part, DİSK President Faruk Eren accused the government of trying to enforce who can and cannot be journalists.

Source: todayzaman

Filed Under: Articles Tagged With: Journalist, struggling, Turkey

CPJ-News Alert: Turkey, photographer denied entry and freelance journalist goes on trial #ArmenianGenocide

April 8, 2015 By administrator

News Alert

Istanbul, April 8, 2015—The Committee to Protect Journalists calls on Turkish authorities to improve conditions for international reporters after news reports said German freelance photographer Andy Spyra, who flew to Istanbul to cover the anniversary of the Armenian massacre, was denied entry to the country. Separately, the trial of Dutch freelance journalist Fréderike Geerdink, who is facing terrorism charges over her reporting on the Kurdish minority, began today, according to news reports.
“Turkey has become increasingly hostile to international journalists, particularly those who cover sensitive topics, such as the plight of the Kurdish and Armenian minorities,” CPJ Europe and Central Asia Program Coordinator Nina Ognianova said. “We call on Turkish authorities to allow journalists to do their work freely, including by scrapping the absurd criminal case against Fréderike Geerdink and allowing entry to Andy Spyra.”
On March 29, Turkish authorities expelled Spyra, who had arrived in Istanbul the day before on assignment for the German magazine Der Spiegel, according to local and international press reports. He was denied entry to the country, detained overnight at the airport, and then put on a plane to Germany, reports said. After he was expelled, Spyra told reporters he had intended to cover the 100th anniversary of the Armenian massacre, a sensitive topic in Turkey. The government refuses to use the term genocide even though historians believe about 1.5 million Armenians were killed.
When he arrived at Istanbul’s Atatürk international airport, plain-clothes security officers took Spyra aside and searched his luggage, paying special attention to his camera and other reporting equipment, according to multiple press reports. Despite support from the German Embassy, authorities citing “security reasons” sent him back to Germany, according to reports. Spyra told reporters that Turkish authorities accused him of having ties to Islamic extremists.
Separately, at today’s hearing in Geerdink’s trial at a criminal court in the southeast regional capital of Diyarbakir, a prosecutor who recently took over the case called for the journalist to be acquitted of all charges. The court is expected to rule in the case on April 13, and Geerdink’s attorney said an acquittal is expected, The Wall Street Journal reported.
Geerdink was indicted on February 1 with “making propaganda” for the banned Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) and Union of Communities in Kurdistan (KCK) through her reporting and social media posts, according to CPJ research. On January 6, terrorism police raided Geerdink’s home, reports said. The journalist, who has been based in Diyarbakir since 2012, was briefly detained and interrogated the same day as part of an investigation into allegations that she created “propaganda for a terrorist organization,” reports said.
A Diyarbakir prosecutor claimed at the time that Geerdink was spreading propaganda through social media posts and her regular column for the independent Turkish news website Diken, according to news reports. As her portfolio on the writers’ platform Beacon shows, Geerdink focuses on covering the plight of the Kurdish minority, politics, and human rights in Turkey.
###
CPJ is an independent, nonprofit organization that works to safeguard press freedom worldwide.
Contact:
Nina Ognianova
Europe and Central Asia Program Coordinator
Tel. +1.212.465.1004 ext. 106
Email: nognianova@cpj.org

Muzaffar Suleymanov

Filed Under: Articles Tagged With: cpj, denied, entry, Journalist, news-alert, Turkey

Turkey exiles German journalist for Genocide article

April 6, 2015 By administrator

f55228ee0537bf_55228ee0537f6.thumbThe Turkish authorities have exiled a German photojournalist who traveled to the country to prepare an article on the Armenian Genocide.

Andy Spyra, who works for the publication Der Spiegel, was forced to return from the airport over alleged links to the Islamic State, the Turkish Radikal reports.

He had earlier been to the country on a visit.

Arriving at the Turkish airport on March 28, Spyra was first arrested and searched; an intervention by the German Embassy appeared to be of no help in terms of preventing the exile.

The photo journalist admitted that he had left for Turkey for preparing a material about the Genocide and cited his previous records as evidence that might have struck the corresponding authorities’ attention.

Filed Under: Articles, Genocide Tagged With: exiles, german, Journalist, Turkey

Turkey: No Day or week go by without Journalist receives jail sentence for “Erdoğan insult”

April 4, 2015 By administrator

GAZİANTEP – Doğan News Agency

Local journalist Yaşar Elma (L) and his lawyer, Dilber Demirel (R). DHA photo

 journalist Yaşar Elma (L) and his lawyer, Dilber Demirel (R). DHA photo

A journalist from a local daily in southeastern Turkey has received a suspended prison sentence for “liking” a remark criticising President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan on Facebook, which the court deemed as an “insult.”

The 19th Criminal Court of First Instance in the Gaziantep province convicted Yaşar Elma on charges of “insulting a public servant” in the second hearing of the trial on April 4, in which Erdoğan’s lawyer also attended.

The court originally ruled to send Elma to prison for 28 months, but decreased the sentence to 23 months before suspending it.

“I had just used the ‘like’ feature of Facebook when I saw a comment on Mr. President one day. I deleted it after half an hour, but the police came up and the court convicted me in the second hearing of the trial,” Elma said in an interview to the Doğan News Agency, noting that he “did not know that liking a comment was a crime.”

His lawyer, Dilber Demirel, stressed that they would appeal the ruling, while stressing that the conviction stems from a single word that the court deemed an insult, without specifying it.

“We think that the ruling is against the law. Because several rulings in the past had stressed that political personalities should tolerate such harsh criticism,” she said.

Demirel also noted that the ruling could be marking a milestone, as it criminalizes the “resharing” of an offensive message shared on social media.

The crime of “insult” is normally punished by three months in prison according to Turkish law. However, if the complainant is a public servant, the prison term is extended to one year. If the “insult” is conveyed “publicly,” such as via a media outlet, the law stipulates an extra one-sixth increase in the prison term.

More than 70 people in Turkey have been prosecuted for “insulting” Erdoğan since he was elected president in August 2014. There were hundreds of similar cases during his term as Turkey’s Prime Minister.

In March 2014, while dogged by accusations of corruption soon before crucial local elections, Erdoğan had threatened to shut down Facebook and YouTube “if necessary” via a controversial law, vowing that he “would not sacrifice the Turkish people” to the two websites.

Most recently, two prominent cartoonists from the popular weekly magazine Penguen received 11-month prison sentences over a satirical piece on free speech which they were convicted of including a hidden gesture “insulting” Erdoğan.

The Vienna-based International Press Institute’s (IPI) Turkish National Committee announced in February that it will start a campaign against the increasing number of defamation lawsuits targeting journalists in Turkey.

The IPI’s special report on Turkey released March 27 concluded that defamation suits and arrests targeting journalists threaten Turkey’s democracy.

 

Filed Under: Articles Tagged With: jail-sentence, Journalist, Turkey

Erdogan has all but destroyed Turkish journalism Yavuz Baydar

March 20, 2015 By administrator

Turkish-riot-policeman-us-008Journalists are being intimidated and imprisoned, while government-friendly moguls are given lucrative contracts. The free media is on the verge of extinction.

‘If alarm for the independence of the Turkish press was already high, those concerns were raised still further soon after the outbreak of the summer demonstrations in 2013 to protect Istanbul’s Gezi Park.’ Photograph: Osman Orsal/Reuters

Among journalists, the truth universally acknowledged is that bad news commands more column inches than good. In Turkey, the even more depressing truism is that much of the bad news has to do with the news industry itself.

Those of us trying to preserve our integrity as journalists fight a constant rearguard action – against proprietors who set little store by integrity, and against a government that tries to accrue power by restricting freedom of expression and ringfencing public debate.

Recent headlines have been devoted to the arrest of the journalist Mehmet Baransu. He was detained for a story he wrote in 2010, based on (literally) a suitcase of military documents, handed over to him by a whistleblowing officer, which implicated senior commanders in an attempted coup d’état, codenamed Sledgehammer.

The subsequent court proceedings – both in their scale and the liberal use of pre-trial detention – proved bitterly controversial. There is little doubt that the government interfered and was more interested in taming its own military than producing justice. The defence was able to cast doubt on the authenticity of some (but by no means all) of the evidence. So there is reason to believe that some of the convictions – suspended pending a retrial – were unsound.

Yet this is not why Baransu has been thrown in prison. He is accused not of misleading the courts but of handling state secrets, despite the fact that he had handed the leaked documents over to state prosecutors. Having got the military under its thumb, the government now requires its cooperation and has turned on the journalist who once made the government’s case.

Worse still, much of the government media is egging the prosecutors on. Imagine Glenn Greenwald being arrested and then the rest of the press urging the authorities to throw away the key. The current state of journalism is only a reflection of how polarised Turkish society has become under the divisive rule of President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan.

Self-censorship is the rule. Many Turkish newsrooms resemble an open prison rather than a creative hive and fear has gripped those of the so-called mainstream media institutions. It is not the fear of ending up in courtrooms or in jail: it is fear of being fired. There is utter professional vulnerability. According to Turkey’s journalist union, only 1.5% of our journalists belong to a union.

The columnist Kadri Gürsel wrote recently that the real aim is to finish off journalism as a whole, and this is a view shared by many. We are witnessing the dismantling of a profession whose independence should be guaranteed by the constitution. The very DNA of Turkey’s fourth estate is being severely tampered with. The aim of the government is to subordinate the media, as a whole if possible, to the political executive.

As I argue in The Newsroom as an Open Air Prison: Corruption and Self-Censorship in Turkish Journalism, a discussion paper that I prepared as Shorenstein Fellow at Harvard Kennedy School last autumn, this is the tragic story of the demise of a profession in one of the most important parts of the world.

This destructive pattern was accelerated by the two police operations in the last days of December 2013, massive investigations into the affairs of four ministers of the majority Justice and Development party (AKP) government. Those touched by the corruption scandals included a number of businessmen with close connections to the government, bureaucrats and bank managers, but also Bilal Erdoğan, son of the prime minister.

Of even greater concern is that the investigations appeared to suggest that senior government figures were engaged in sanctions-busting against Iran, and that these senior figures had links to financiers who laundered funds for al-Qaida.

The files compiled by law enforcement and prosecutors were a burning fuse: they claimed to expose a vast network of organised crime, with evidence of bribery, abuse of power and widespread corruption at the very highest echelons of power.Corruption of the nation’s media was at the heart of these allegations. A critical part of the investigation – backed by legal wiretappings – concerned consortiums to co-finance media entirely in favour of the AKP government. This joint effort, in which businessmen benefiting from government contracts paid into a common slush fund, gave rise to the term “pool media”.

A landmark in this targeting of media independence was reached with the blackout implemented by the media itself on the story of 34 Kurdish villagers killed by Turkish fighter jets in the Iraqi border village of Uludere/Roboski in late 2011. That silence became a dress rehearsal for the media surrendering its role as the watchdog of the public interest.

Yet if alarm for the independence of the Turkish press was already high, those concerns were raised still further soon after the outbreak of the summer demonstrations in 2013 to protect Istanbul’s Gezi Park. Protests spread to 78 of the 81 provinces in Turkey. The degree of self-censorship became so intense that the mainstream Turkish media itself became the subject of demonstration and open ridicule. Even so, Erdoğan declared that critical media – domestic and international – were part of a conspiracy to topple him and his government from power. Thereafter the demonisation of independent journalism gathered pace. Journalists who tried to defend their independence and dignity found themselves fired or dispatched to professional limbo.

The developing story of high-level corruption (reaching the very heights of the political establishment – a dream for any decent journalist anywhere in the world) was declared by the news management to be an area surrounded by “barbed wire.” Thus, 2014 began with a self-censorship more institutionalised and internalised than ever before. Blocked by political and institutional pressure, the core of Turkey’s dedicated and defiant journalists migrated their craft online. Social media and independent news sites began to fill a vacuum. The government’s reaction was to try to shut down YouTube and Twitter, but this proved technically difficult and legally unsuccessful.

Still Erdoğan is undeterred; the internet remains a target and vulnerable to government interference. Between 2013 and the end of 2014, the government imposed more than 20 news blackouts on important stories, on various grounds including national security. This was a normalisation of censorship.

Intimidation is normal, too. According to the latest report on 2014 by Independent Communication Network (BiA) there are currently 22 journalists in jail. More than 61 have been found guilty of defamation against Erdoğan in the past three years. On 14 December 2014 two of the remaining critical media outlets – Zaman and STV – were raided, their top managers arrested. Hidayet Karaca, the general manager of Samanyolu Media Group, has been detained for more than 80 days. His charges arise from a TV script.

This continuing process cannot be described as anything other than a purge. The Turkish media industry is systematically losing its qualified workforce, its remaining ethics are vanishing.

With the business groups on board, Erdoğan has simply raised the stakes to enforce dependence: in return for lucrative public contracts, all the media moguls in Turkey have to put their outlets in the service of power. It is a system based on corruption that also requires full complicity. If Erdoğan or his aides do not call the top managers and editors of the media to publish propaganda or censor undesirable content, the owners themselves do it.

The notion of journalism as a check on the irresponsible, corrupt or unfettered exercise of power is evaporating. Investigative reporting, more crucial than ever, is on the verge of extinction. Our democracy now depends on whether the Turkish media can escape the quagmire into which one man’s ambition has driven it.

Filed Under: Articles Tagged With: destroyed, Erdogan, Journalist, Turkey

Veteran Turkish journalist Hasan Cemal receives prestigious journalism award

March 13, 2015 By administrator

Turkish journalist Hasan Cemal (Photo: Cihan, Orhan Akkurt)

Turkish journalist Hasan Cemal (Photo: Cihan, Orhan Akkurt)

Turkish journalist Hasan Cemal who was named by Harvard University as its 2015 recipient of the Louis M. Lyons award for Conscience and Integrity in Journalism received the award at a ceremony at the university on Thursday. the author of book the Armenian Genocide,

Cemal was chosen by Harvard’s Nieman Foundation “in recognition of a long career dedicated to championing freedom of the press in Turkey and as a representative of all Turkish journalists working today under increasingly difficult conditions.” report todayzaman

In a statement, members of the Nieman Foundation said: “Hasan Cemal and Turkish journalists like him have shown great courage in upholding the importance of a free press in their native land. Bearing witness and speaking truth to power are more necessary than ever in Turkey and other places around the world where journalists face government hostility, harassment, and arrest.”

The full text of the speech Cemal delivered during the award ceremony is as follows:

I know you’ve all seen those Oscar ceremonies where the award winner weeps and struggles to find the right words.

 Let’s face it; a journalist lost for words wouldn’t be much of a journalist.

The real danger is that by the time I’ve finished my speech, you might be wishing I were lost for words.

So I will try to be brief.

I said “try.”

I make no promises.

And even though my eyes are dry, I won’t begin to conceal that this is an emotional moment for me.

As journalists, we all share a secret. We are motivated by the impact we make, not the size of our monthly payslip. And there is no greater recognition than the respect of our own peers.

And which peers command more respect than the Nieman Fellows?

So let me begin by thanking you all so very much for this award. It means a great deal.

When I look at the list of people who have received this award in previous years, when I consider that I may be thought worthy to sit among such towering talents, as Edward R. Murrow, I think maybe I have done something with my life after all.

This award means much to me but I believe it means a great deal to the journalistic community in Turkey whom I represent – or at least those members of that community who are still prepared to listen to their conscience, who are still prepared to try to hold power accountable and who are still prepared to put their jobs, and even on occasion their own liberty on the line.

It was George Orwell who defined freedom as the right to tell people what they do not want to hear.

Please be assured: In Turkey there are still members of our profession who cherish that right and who are still prepared to defend that notion of freedom.

Let me tell you a little about them and about Turkey, the country where I have made my career.

I come from a country where a journalist was arrested and her mobile phone and computer seized because of a single tweet; a country where, for that single tweet, she faces five years in prison.

I come from a country where a prime minister has declared social media to be a social menace.

I come from a country where Twitter and YouTube were banned by government fiat.

I come from a country where all a prime minister has to do is pick up the phone for a news item to be spiked, or a journalists fired. This is a land where the prime minister can even decide who will or will not appear on a talk show.

I come from a country where a prime minister can scold a newspaper owner down the phone about an article he published to such an extent that he reduced the man to actual tears.

I know this because the boss was my boss -a man who made his fortune not through newsprint but through his business dealings with the government. So when the prime minister scolded he was in no position to answer back.

And the reason the prime minister was angry enough to make the man cry was because of something I wrote.

Allow me the luxury of quoting from myself:

“Producing a newspaper is one thing; running a country is another. Nobody should confuse the two, nor feel entitled to cross the line.

I know the line is a thin one, which is why in democracies all hell sometimes breaks loose.

Look at the outcry caused in America by the Bay of Pigs Invasion, the Vietnam War, the Pentagon Papers and the Watergate Scandal, and look at how many times valued members of the journalist profession in America were accused of treason by presidents and those who govern.

But history has always been on the side of those newspapers and journalists who, through news and editorials, stood up for peace, democracy and freedom of the press.”

I continue to quote:

It was back in the early 1990s. I was editor in chief of a newspaper called Cumhuriyet . One of the big names of the Turkish business community asked for my advice as he intended to launch a newspaper.

I asked him:

“Why do you intend to launch a newspaper? Do you want to have a ‘successful newspaper’ alongside a successful fridge and a TV factory and a successful bank? Or do you want to launch a newspaper to leverage political influence that will be greater than your rivals and competitors? Do you want to get into the newspaper business or use the newspaper to protect your real business?”

That question is more than valid today.

It is at the heart of the corrupt and unwholesome relation between those in power and those whose business it is to make power accountable.

But not only that.

It explains why a journalist elite in Turkey fail to do their jobs. Editors and leading columnists fail to defend journalism against those in power because they are unable to protect journalism from their bosses. The profession is divided and weak.

In order for the relationship between media and government to acquire public legitimacy, in order for the relationship between journalism and owners to obey ground rules built on respect, it goes without saying that journalists themselves must recover their own sense of integrity.

We cannot sit back as if our hands were tied. Our inaction marks the death knell of democracy and an end to the rule of law.

The column was never published in the newspaper I had worked for 15 years.

It was enough to get me fired.

But of course I had it published on the same day, at the on line newspaper T24, where I have been writing for the last two years.

Let me tell you a few other things about the country where I come from. It is a place where, during an election rally, the prime minister provokes the crowd to jeer at journalists– threatening women journalists in particular.

I come from a country where a prime minister declares those who hold different opinions from his own to be traitors.

In Turkey the prime minister appointed as Minister of the Interior his own undersecretary, a man who gave the order to a local governor to, [and I quote] “Break down that journalist’s door and throw him in jail… If the prosecutor complains, throw him in jail too…”

I come from a country where a prime minister’s undersecretary can say, “Shut down that journalist’s website! So what if there’s no court order? We’re the ones who make the laws, my friend.. I’m talking about the will of a party that received 50 percent of the vote. Don’t worry about it; excuse my language but screw the lot of them…”

I come from a country where the prime minister has ensured that the profits from the large government tenders he controls, are used to create media empires under his influence; where he has the final say on the appointment of editors-in-chief and columnists, and on basic editorial issue.

Not surprisingly this has resulted in a one-sided media totally under his control.

I wish I could stop here. I know I promised to try to be brief.

But there’s more.

I live in a country where there is an abuse of power and a media that is too intimidated to write about those abuses.

The result is no great secret– it is the degradation of rule of law.

We have seen the prime minister can get his own Minister of Justice to use his influence in the Supreme Court to overturn the acquittal of an important media tycoon;

…Where he can withdraw a large government tender from a group he dislikes and award it to a group that he favors…

Where a prime minister can, at a moment’s notice, remove judges and police officers from their posts in order to cover-up claims of corruption and theft that reach as far as his own family…

Instead of ‘rule of law’ we have a ‘police state’.

We have come to understand that a police state is one where the police do not obey the orders of the public prosecutor.

It is one where those who defend the rule of law – including the head of the Constitutional Court are attacked for opposing the rule of the majority – even when that means shutting down Twitter and YouTube.

In Turkey, the head of the country’s largest business organisation is labelled a traitor for defending the rule of law as essential to business confidence.

The prime minister has even accused the Central Bank governor of treason for not lowering interest rates.

We have witnessed a prime minister become so insensitive that he encourages his supporters to boo the mourning mother of a 15-year-old boy who was killed by police during a protest…

…a prime minister that meddles in people’s private lives, who pronounces on  everything from the length of girls’ skirts, to the number of children a family should have.

I know this is beginning to sound personal. So let me name names. I am talking about Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, prime minister for over a decade and since August, the Turkish president.

He is moving Turkey towards what he calls a presidential system but which is tantamount to one man-rule.

He has no respect for the rule of law.

He has no concern for the independence of the judiciary.

He does not recognize the separation of powers.

He believes that democracy simply means a majority at the ballot box.

He has not learned that getting the most votes is not a license to violate democratic values, nor to force the surrender of the judiciary, nor to ignore the separation of powers, to trample on freedom of expression, to destroy free and independent media, nor to subjugate civil society.

If he hasn’t learned this by now, the chances are he never will.

He is a man who could have led Turkey into the family of democracies, but who is now leading it back to the wilderness.

We are moving from a system of ‘military bureaucratic tutelage’ to a system of ‘civilian despotism’.

And all this is called by his partisans, the new Turkey and even a ‘people’s revolution’.

Today, the choice Turkey faces is whether it can still embrace fundamental values that turn the illusion of  democracy into real democracy.

In Turkey I am known for having coined the expression “gazeteci milleti” or the “journalist nation.”

The main qualification for citizenship of this nation is the ability to ask questions.

Questioning is a way of life for us. And for this reason we are not particularly popular.

And those who require not just 99 per cent but 100 per cent submission, don’t really like the “journalist nation.”

For example, in Turkey, President Erdoğan refuses to meet with journalists who may ask him any uncomfortable questions.

It has been years since he held a real press conference.

He can only be in the presence of journalists whom he knows will play by his rules. If, by chance, someone finds the opportunity to rear their head and ask a real question, they will find themselves on the receiving end of a severe dressing-down.

But journalists will continue to ask questions.

No dictator can divest journalists of this democratic right.

There will always be those who, for the right reason not just the wrong, want to leave the Journalist Nation. There always have been and there always will.

But there will always be those who have no choice. We are creatures of the Journalist Nation. It is the only place we can still breathe.

The following words by the Peruvian novelist Vargas Llosa stick in my mind:

“The situation of the writer is one of constant rebellion, the role of devil’s advocate.”

He continues:

“… just as we did today and yesterday, we must continue to move forward in society, saying “no”, rebelling, demanding the recognition of our right to think differently…

… showing that dogma, censorship and arbitrary rule are the mortal enemies of progress and human dignity…

Yes, we must continue moving forward.

But for how long?

I am 71 years old.

I have been an active journalist for 46 years. I have never worked in any other job.

During the 2006 World Cup in Germany, I spent a month writing about that leather ball. I remember one particular day very clearly. I was taking a train to Berlin for a match. While browsing the Daily Telegraph, I read an interview with a journalist who was celebrating his 75th year in the job.

Next to the article was a black-and-white photograph of the journalist sitting by the window of a train, writing. During the celebratory dinner someone asked him:

“Why, at the age of 93, do you still switch on your computer every day?”

He answered by quoting the famous Housman poem:

“Up, lad; when the journey’s over, there’ll be time enough to sleep.”

I hope not all of you are asleep. I really am nearly done.

I have told you about the country I come from. But I know full well there are many countries whose journalists could stand here and make a similar speech. And it is not only journalists who suffer oppression.

There are many others who live under the pressure of dictatorship.

So if you ask me, what journalists do that makes them different, it is that we are the  voice of those who have no voice.

We cry out where others cannot.

And we make the whole world hear the cry that would otherwise remain lodged in the people’s throat.

What I am describing is not just true of underdeveloped countries. As a profession, we must find ways to make ourselves heard – to shout with an ever firmer voice.

I have devoted my life to this profession, and there have been times when I have asked myself whether it was worth it; and frankly sometimes I had to answer “no”.

When that happens, “Hasan CemaI,” I tell myself, “You  never had a choice. What other job could you do?”

That was before I got fired. But when I did get fired I did what any member of the Journalist Nation would do.

I started all over again.

In my case it was T24 one of Turkey’s new and brave on line newspaper.

A few days after I was told to put down my pen, I walked up a mountain on the Turkish Iraqi border with retreating Kurdish guerrillas. I went into the field to report and to write.

And when I got home, I began devoting time to founding an organization called P24, a civil society organization which encourages editorial independence and quality journalism.

How do we do that?

The first step is not to give up.

That too is not always easy.

But on a day like today, standing before an audience of distinguished colleagues, witnessing solidarity and friendship, I realize that my modest struggle is shared. So ask me on a day like today whether devoting an entire life to journalism was worth it.

This award is the answer.

Yes, it was worth it.

Thank you all for this day, for this prize and for your attention.

Filed Under: Articles Tagged With: award, Hasan Cemal, Journalist, Turkish

News Alert: Turkish journalist charged with obtaining secret documents used in Sledgehammer case

March 4, 2015 By administrator

 logo-smallNews Alert Committee to Protect Journalists

New York, March 4, 2015—The Committee to Protect Journalists calls on Turkish authorities to release Mehmet Baransu, a columnist and correspondent for the privately-owned daily newspaper Taraf, who has been charged with obtaining secret documents and held in custody since March 1, according to news reports.

Police searched Baransu’s house in Istanbul on March 1 and detained him in connection with documents he received from an unidentified source in 2010, according to news reports. The documents were the basis for a widely reported investigation and trial related to an alleged military coup plot known as Sledgehammer.

Sercan Sakallı, the lawyer for Baransu, told CPJ a court order has branded the investigation secret and Baransu’s defense team does not yet know what evidence the prosecution has against him. He added that authorities have focused on a specific document, titled “The Sovereign Action Plan” that was part of a packet of documents Baransu shared with prosecutors in 2010. That document, the lawyer said, was never made public, and authorities did not previously question the reporter’s possession of a classified document.
Baransu was taken to Istanbul’s Metris Prison on March 2, according to news reports. No trial date has been set yet, Sakallı told CPJ. If convicted, Baransu faces up to eight years in prison, according to Turkey’s penal code.

“A journalist’s job is to report on developments in the public interest, and it is absurd that a journalist should be prosecuted for obtaining documents—which in any case were shared with authorities,” CPJ Europe and Central Asia Program Coordinator Nina Ognianova said. “We call on Turkish authorities to immediately release Mehmet Baransufrom custody and drop allcharges against him.”

Taraf was the first paper to report on the purported coup, based on the documents obtained by Baransu according to reports . Baransu also shared the documents he received from the source with Turkish prosecutors in 2010 according to Tarafand other reports. According to police interrogation documents reviewed by CPJ, Baransu never revealed his source.

On March 3, Taraf’s founding editor Ahmet Altan defended Baransu in an op-ed
published by the daily Cumhuriyet . “Since when have coup plans been classified as ‘documents related to state security’ and ‘state knowledge that needs to be kept classified?’” wrote Altan. “I am the person who published the [Sledgehammer] story, the one who decided it needed to be published, the one who didn’t doubt for a moment that Sledgehammer was a coup plot.”

The case against Baransu comes amid increasing tension between the Turkish ruling party, the AKP, and its once-ally-turned-foe, the Gülen movement, an organization tied to U.S.-based Islamic cleric Fethullah Gülen. The AKP backed Sledgehammer prosecutions several years ago but has since backtracked, blaming the Gülen movement with fabricating evidence, newsreports said. In June, Turkey’s Constitutional Court ordered the release of more than 230 military officers, previously imprisoned in the case, according to reports.

Filed Under: Articles Tagged With: charged, Journalist, Turkish

  • « Previous Page
  • 1
  • …
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
  • 12
  • Next Page »

Support Gagrule.net

Subscribe Free News & Update

Search

GagruleLive with Harut Sassounian

Can activist run a Government?

Wally Sarkeesian Interview Onnik Dinkjian and son

https://youtu.be/BiI8_TJzHEM

Khachic Moradian

https://youtu.be/-NkIYpCAIII
https://youtu.be/9_Xi7FA3tGQ
https://youtu.be/Arg8gAhcIb0
https://youtu.be/zzh-WpjGltY





gagrulenet Twitter-Timeline

Tweets by @gagrulenet

Archives

Books

Recent Posts

  • Pashinyan Government Pays U.S. Public Relations Firm To Attack the Armenian Apostolic Church
  • Breaking News: Armenian Former Defense Minister Arshak Karapetyan Pashinyan is agent
  • November 9: The Black Day of Armenia — How Artsakh Was Signed Away
  • @MorenoOcampo1, former Chief Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, issued a Call to Action for Armenians worldwide.
  • Medieval Software. Modern Hardware. Our Politics Is Stuck in the Past.

Recent Comments

  • Baron Kisheranotz on Pashinyan’s Betrayal Dressed as Peace
  • Baron Kisheranotz on Trusting Turks or Azerbaijanis is itself a betrayal of the Armenian nation.
  • Stepan on A Nation in Peril: Anything Armenian pashinyan Dismantling
  • Stepan on Draft Letter to Armenian Legal Scholars / Armenian Bar Association
  • administrator on Turkish Agent Pashinyan will not attend the meeting of the CIS Council of Heads of State

Copyright © 2025 · News Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in